Subscribe to the::unwired's RSS Feedthe::unwired at Twitterthe::unwired on Facebookthe::unwired on Google Plus
the::unwired Article
THOUGHT: Who locked down the Windows Mobile Smartphone Start Menu? [UPDATE]
Posted by Arne Hess - on Wednesday, 04.04.07 - 13:51:40 CET under 09 - Thoughts - Viewed 22066x
Tagged under: [] [] []

Oh man, this topic is annoying me and it's not the first time that it annoys me but now I want and have to rant about it because it starts to seriously hurt (me). One of the benefits of having a Smartphone is the fact that it is a kind of micro computer. So far so good and with most Smartphones you can install your own applications to make it even better and provide the appropriate applications for your needs.
However something is wrong here and it's a basic customization functionality. Sure, I can change the Home Screen look & feel of a Windows Mobile Smartphone and if I'm a little bit talented I can even create my own Home Screens by tweaking the Home Screen definition file (which is a XML file). If I'm less talented I can download great 3rd party Home Screens (most of the for free) but for some reasons I cannot change the Start Menu order.

Put it this way: I'm a pretty "traditional" PC and mobile phone user and I love to group everything in directories. For instance on my PCs I have a pretty clean Start Menu where I have grouped all applications in (for me) meaningful categories:

As you can see above - I don't have too many categories on the first level which provides a pretty sleek look & feel and since I've used the first Windows Mobile Pocket PC, I always did the same with my Pocket PC Start Menu and Programs folder to get a similar look & feel:

However, for some reasons this regrouping isn't allowed (anymore) with Windows Mobile Smartphones. Let me take the Samsung SGH-i600 as an example (but same happens with other Smartphones, it's not Samsung related). I don't want to have such a crowdie Start Menu which requires a lot of scrolling:

No, I would prefer something cleaner like this (which is a very old topic Carlo wrote about in his tip: '"8" is the Smartphone's sweet number'):

But no, if you follow Carlo's tip today, doesn't matter if you try it on your Smartphone or via the PC's Explorer, you are not allowed to change anything. On the Smartphone the Cut & Paste option isn't available and therefore you cannot move a simple shortcut:

Now, if you think you can be smart and edit the Start Menu folder via your PC you will notice that the shortcuts are write protected:

Oh no? I don't have the permission to move a simple shortcut (except from the applications I installed myself since these files are not write protected ROM files) on my own phone? Who the heck made Start Menu shortcuts protected System files?

With the very early Smartphones, for instance the i-mate Smartphones from HTC, these files weren't protected at all but you was allowed to reorder the Start Menu. However, also the latest HTC phones got this protection. Thankfully there was a kind of unofficial unlocker available which changed the Registry values to unlock the files again but this unlocker is working with HTC Smartphones only (and it's not supporting Windows Mobile 6 anymore). Other manufactures aren't supported and therefore, there is no way to easily edit the Start Menu of a Windows Mobile Smartphone - without deep-diving into the Registry.

What the heck? Who thinks to know me better than myself? Who wants to dictate me how my very own Start Menu has to look like? I don't know, I've addressed it at both - Microsoft and the manufactures but nothing changed so far and therefore I think it's time to bring this topic to everybody's attention.

Would either Microsoft or the manufactures please stop with this stupid paternalism of the customers? We know best how our Start Menus should look like. It's appreciated if a suggestion is made, after a device is switched on the first time, but it shouldn't be that hard coded at all.

UPDATE: Here we go, if anyone else is looking for a solution as well, the good old SDA Security Unlocker also works fine on the i600! Now my Smartphone looks like I want to have it but anyway - why to force customers to run such software (even if this piece of software is trustworthy)?

Cheers ~ Arne


 
Related Links

Related Articles THOUGHT:

Comments
Posted by dropacid on 25.04.07 - 23:51:39

http://www.modaco.com/TotW-Change-Hardc … 06818.html

Posted by Mary Branscombe on 26.04.07 - 16:34:09

With Vista and the Mobile Device Center, how do you even *get* into the Windows folder?

Posted by Mary Branscombe on 26.04.07 - 16:46:18

Less too lazy and more too disorganised. For the benefit of anyone else puzzled by the tellytubby friendly interface, you need to turn on Show hidden and OS files in Explorer and then you can see it - Computer\Mary's Dash\\\Windows\Start Menu. I can move any shortcut I've installed myself without a problem, so it must only be pre-installed shortcuts that are locked. Still irritating...

Posted by Arne Hess on 26.04.07 - 18:12:30

Yes, quite frustrating to enable hidden and OS files which also shows the "desktop.ini" on the Vista Desktop. hmm
Anyway - with the above mentioned SDA-Unlocker (you have to run on your PC while you device is ActiveSync'd) you are able to rearrange the pre-installed shortcuts as well.
An I like this way way more than editing the Registry which could screw up your device and might force you to hard reset it. Rearranging via the File Explorer is the easiest and fastest way!

Social Sharing
     
This Week's Top Stories
Feeds & More
Awards & More
Recent Discussions
© Copyright 1998 - 2013 by the::unwired® & Arne Hess
All rights reserved!
the::unwired is a registered trademark of Arne Hess.
All trademarks are owned by their respective companies.
All site video, graphic and text content is copyrighted to the respective party and may not be reproduced without express written consent.