Who Calculated these UMTS Tariffs?
Posted by Arne Hess - at Wednesday, 23.05.07 - 18:08:50 CET under Wireless - Mobile Networks - Viewed 10568x
It's not a secret that the carrier of my choice is O2 (Germany). Maybe it's
because its innovative Genion product, maybe it's because I worked for O2's
forerunner VIAG Interkom for 3 years, maybe it's just because I like the whole
Anyway, as happy as I'm with O2 (Germany), as frustrated I was with O2's data
tariffs. Even in the past, when I was the responsible product manager for VIAG
Interkom's WAP service, I had some hard fights with Controlling to get the WAP
tariffs in the Homezone reduced and it took ages until O2 reduced their GPRS and
UMTS tariffs earlier this year. Therefore I signed a 24 month contract back in
2005 with E-Plus (another German GSM & UMTS carrier) for one simple reason:
E-Plus was the first carrier in Germany which offered a true GPRS & UMTS flat
rate. However, signing a second contract means you get a second SIM card and so
on. I prefer to have everything under one contract especially because O2 offers
a service called "MultiCard" which gives you up to 3 SIM cards under one mobile
number (without any additional monthly fees). This means you can use one SIM in
your mobile phone, one SIM in your Pocket PC and one SIM in your Notebook. While
only one SIM gets incoming calls, all 3 SIM cards can be used for outgoing calls
(but not in parallel) and - this is even more important - all the SIM cards can
be used in parallel for data connections!
This means I can send a MMS from my mobile phone while I surf the O2 WAP pages
the same time while I still stay connected with my Notebook to O2's UMTS
network. That's indeed pretty handy and smart!
Therefore I was even happier when O2 reduced its monthly data pack fees
earlier this year - as said since I thought to cancel my E-Plus contract after
the 24 month to switch back to O2 for my data. Before, I roughly paid 10 Euro
per month for 20 MB and now I pay the same price for 200 MB. If I'm going to
cancel my E-Plus subscription, I will upgrade my current 200 MB plan to the 5 GB
plan which is available for 25 Euro (and I will save 49 Euro per month I'm
currently paying at E-Plus). Not to bad at all but what happens if you reach the
At E-Plus, I don't have any limits and I can use as much as I need (which is
pretty handy for place-shifting TV for example). Unfortunately E-Plus isn't
offering HSDPA at the moment and for web surfing, they use a network compression
which reduces the image quality. Something I cannot accept, especially if I have
to work mobile. On the other hand, E-Plus offers Hot- or at least Warm-Billing.
If I login to my account, I can see how much data each session consumed and how
much data I used for the current month.
O2 is offering HSDPA (at least in some areas) and isn't compressing pictures
- so it's another good reason for me to switch to them. However, all O2 data
packs have a limit (either 200 MB or 5 GB) and after you are charged per
consumed MB again. If I do some math now, I wonder who has calculated the
200 MB = 10 Euro = 0,05 Euro per MB
5000 MB = 25 Euro = 0,005 Euro per MB
So far so good and definitely a fair deal. However, if you use more than the
200 MB/5 GB, O2 charges you 0,50 Euro per additional MB! Shouldn't it be
something like 0,05 Euro/0,005 Euro or in worst case 0,10 Euro/0,01 Euro? But
it's 10/100 time more than the price per included MB:
Sorry O2 - you know I like you but this is a freaking rip-off and I see no
reason why an additional MB have to be charged 10/100 times higher than the
Unfortunately this isn't the only problem. While 5 GB are pretty good at all
- I hardly came over it with my E-Plus subscription - O2 is neither offering
Hot- nor Warm-Billing. This means I cannot verify how much volume I've consumed
per month already but I have to await the next invoice! That's not funny at all,
if you keep in mind that watching one minute place-shifted TV consumes something
between 1 and 1.5 MB (depending on the quality and bandwidth). So every
additional minute costs me 50 to 75 Cent? Well, that's heavy and I better let my
Slingbox off. Or I have to stay with E-Plus.
Unfortunately O2 isn't offering a fair-flat policy, like T-Mobile or Vodafone
Germany who aren't charging any additional volume if you reach it one month only
but stay within your limit the next month again. O2 is charging the additional
price - from the 201st MB/50001st MB.
Okay, note to myself: "Never do such frustrating mathematics again or better
do it again before you definitely switch away from E-Plus to another carrier."
Cheers ~ Arne
Rate this post: (data provided from NewsGator Online)