Subscribe to the::unwired's RSS Feedthe::unwired at Twitterthe::unwired at Facebookthe::unwired on Google Plus
Top Stories
the::unwired forum
You are not logged in.
You are here: the::unwired - forum / Thoughts / THOUGHT: Comparing a 3.5 inches Xda III screen with a 2.8 inches MPx screen Topic closed! This topic automatically closed 30 days after first posting.
#1

Arne Hess

Editor in Chief

From: Munich or Wireless Cyberspace
Registered: 01.01.1970
Posts: 6187

Website

My last thought "And now? What's your favorite Pocket PC Phone Edition?" generated a couple of good questions and one was about the screen size of the different devices.

While I don't have all the new devices here to compare, at least two typical representatives of the next coming Pocket PC Phone Editions already arrived for testing:


* The o2 Xda III with the typical Pocket PC screen size of 3.5 inches

* The newly introduced screen size of 2.8 inches the Motorola MPx has.


In reality the difference is significant:


[Read More]


Cheers ~ Arne

Founder & Editor in Chief the::unwired
Follow Arne Hess or the::unwired on Twitter - Become a Fan of the::unwired on Facebook

#2

Niels

I'm too lazy to register

Hi Arne,

when can we expect tests of those two devices? And do have any idea on launch dates? Especially for the O2 version of the XDAIII?

Cheers
Niels


This posting was contributed by a unregistered visitor of the::unwired Forum!
the::unwired isn't responsible for any contributions.
#3

msmobiles.com

I'm too lazy to register

Your comparison is a little in vain because both displays have the same resolution - 240x320 pixels. Anyway for many many people small size of Motorola MPx - as compared to other Pocket PC phones - is very crucial! Our only worry is: when at last Motorola MPx will be available commercially!


This posting was contributed by a unregistered visitor of the::unwired Forum!
the::unwired isn't responsible for any contributions.
#4

farnold

I'm too lazy to register

Arne, you hit the spot. I played with both devices as well and I have to say there are quite some reasons that make me to prefer the larger screen. The MPx is a nice concept, but I'm wondering why they didn't make it a Smartphone instead of a PocketPC. For my taste the screen is too small and I didn't see the value of the keyboard... besides that I found it difficult to use with one hand as well... For the moment my conclusion is that my next device will be my current XDA II  big_smile


This posting was contributed by a unregistered visitor of the::unwired Forum!
the::unwired isn't responsible for any contributions.
#5

Arne Hess

Editor in Chief

From: Munich or Wireless Cyberspace
Registered: 01.01.1970
Posts: 6187

Website

One thing I can say is that I've been usign a 2.8 inch screen for almost a year already and I would have to agree with Arne about it's useability as a touch screen device. I find it more difficult to even use the scroll bars as they are much smaller physically.

The 2.8 inch screen may appear sharper since it does offer a tighter dot pitch than nthe regular 3.5 inch screen, but using the SIP keyboard is a bit of a pain when you are trying to poke at keys which are significantly smaller. Errors occur at a higher rate with the SIP QWERTY keyboard and shifting to other forms of writing become essential to keep the useability of the smaller touch screen.

With the MPx, I guess this is addressed by the built-in QWERTY thumb board... but for those who rely mostly on the stylus/touchscreen interface, it will take a lot of getting used to.

I think it would be nice if Arne can also compare this 2.8 inch screen to a 3.8 inch iPAQ h5550 screen to actually show how much smaller this screen is... it's about 1/2 the size of an iPAQ h5550 screen!

Mabuhay! ~ Carlo


Cheers ~ Arne

Founder & Editor in Chief the::unwired
Follow Arne Hess or the::unwired on Twitter - Become a Fan of the::unwired on Facebook

#6

Arne Hess

Editor in Chief

From: Munich or Wireless Cyberspace
Registered: 01.01.1970
Posts: 6187

Website

While the 2.8 screen is generally working fine for me, in in terms of browsing the web, reading E-Mails, using it for Calendar or Contacts and as Carlo said - thanks to the keyboard also entering texts works fine, I found one serious problem with such a small screen: GPS car navigation! The screen is too small to see anything while you are driving. For sure voice commands works fine but mostly you also want to see where you are and where to drive too.


Cheers ~ Arne

Founder & Editor in Chief the::unwired
Follow Arne Hess or the::unwired on Twitter - Become a Fan of the::unwired on Facebook

#7

nojetlag

I'm too lazy to register

I won't touch any mobile device anymore until it is 640 x 480, at the moment they still charge a big extra for such devices (as if it is a big revolution to have VGA). But when prices come down then I might get a device again (if data prices are down then smile )
If you have a 640 x 480 device would you mind to post a comparision ?


This posting was contributed by a unregistered visitor of the::unwired Forum!
the::unwired isn't responsible for any contributions.
#8

bnycastro

I'm too lazy to register

Arne

nice article... a question if you don't mind. how useable/un-useable is the htc blue angel's qwerty keyboard in landscape mode?


This posting was contributed by a unregistered visitor of the::unwired Forum!
the::unwired isn't responsible for any contributions.
#9

Arne Hess

Editor in Chief

From: Munich or Wireless Cyberspace
Registered: 01.01.1970
Posts: 6187

Website

[6] There is no functionality at all, if the Blue Angel is in landscape mode. Here it acts like the Xda II - if it would support Windows Mobile 2003 SE!
Useless unlike the MPx keyboard which can be used in portrait mode at least for dialing.


Cheers ~ Arne

Founder & Editor in Chief the::unwired
Follow Arne Hess or the::unwired on Twitter - Become a Fan of the::unwired on Facebook

#10

losers always complain -bout everything.

I'm too lazy to register

[2] You are definetly a looser.

No wonder why nobody visits your webpage anymore.
Get a life kiddo..


This posting was contributed by a unregistered visitor of the::unwired Forum!
the::unwired isn't responsible for any contributions.
#11

Arne Hess

Editor in Chief

From: Munich or Wireless Cyberspace
Registered: 01.01.1970
Posts: 6187

Website

[1] Tests are still under work but currently I'm super busy with my "real life work" that I'm a "Little bit" limited in my spare time where I can do these tests. Sorry for that!
So far no official release date given for the MPx but beginning next year seems to be reasonable while O2 said until end of this year for the Xda III.


Cheers ~ Arne

Founder & Editor in Chief the::unwired
Follow Arne Hess or the::unwired on Twitter - Become a Fan of the::unwired on Facebook

#12

i-m an idion

I'm too lazy to register

[9] *lol* big_smile couldn't agree more! i enjoy arnes comparison; unlike mswho? it is providing some real value, not like this yellow press styled mswho?!

@arne: sorry for being off-topic!


This posting was contributed by a unregistered visitor of the::unwired Forum!
the::unwired isn't responsible for any contributions.
#13

Niels

I'm too lazy to register

[10] Well, it seems hard to understand why O2 takes so long to release this devices. Franky, T-Mobile is a bigger company and they are not as efficient therefore and they have a shorter time to market then O2. Putting a different case around the device might not take very long...
Long really forward to your tests...


This posting was contributed by a unregistered visitor of the::unwired Forum!
the::unwired isn't responsible for any contributions.
#14

mckytm_temp

I'm too lazy to register

[11] Haha tongue well, the few times I went there I only found prevalent Nokia-bashing articles... I remember reading how Nokia was an evil corporation, and they came from Finland which once had a military pact with the Soviet Union... blah blah blah tongue


This posting was contributed by a unregistered visitor of the::unwired Forum!
the::unwired isn't responsible for any contributions.
#15

jayson

I'm too lazy to register

Back to the screen topic:

A smaller screen might be harder for the eye to handle because even the words will be smaller.  Of course you can increase font size while sacrificing the amount of data presented.  But for a PDA... the larger the screen the better.  (That's why I dumped the SE P800 for an iPAQ). 

Motorola should release this already.  The more they keep it, the more obsolete this becomes even before official release.  By the time they release this, the features may already be not at par with the current generation of PDA's.


This posting was contributed by a unregistered visitor of the::unwired Forum!
the::unwired isn't responsible for any contributions.
Pages: 1 2
Topic closed! This topic automatically closed 30 days after first posting.
© Copyright 1998 - 2013 by the::unwired® & Arne Hess
All rights reserved!
the::unwired is a registered trademark of Arne Hess.
All trademarks are owned by their respective companies.
All site video, graphic and text content is copyrighted to the respective party and may not be reproduced without express written consent.